Monday, September 28, 2026

Bharatendu Harishchandra, T. Sadasivam, and Kishan Patnaik

 Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra My life as ideology 

Join us LIVE and watch @DigantaWrites in conversation with @AloPal , speak on Hindutva in the Intellectual Heritage of Bengal. Live Link: youtube.com/live/VwLfVg6wj…

https://x.com/PondyLitFest/status/2104107661696659847

Listen and learn as Dr. M. R. Venkatesh speaks to @deepscribble on his latest book "Discovery of Bharat: Christian Constitution in a Hindu Nation". Don't miss. Live Link: youtube.com/live/VwLfVg6wj…

https://x.com/PondyLitFest/status/2104175206298435630

Vikram ji points to the core of the issue here. 'Institutions' are not organizations, institutions create the conditions and constraints that organizations adopt. Organizations then create the path dependence for institutional evolution. Cultural production is the deliverable of the capital class and that is the deep lever that we are failing at. We've written about 'why the rich are different now' here. This needs to change. brhat.in/dhiti/the-civi…

https://x.com/Anviksiki/status/2104258643252367789

And this is where PM Modi differs from other leaders in the world. In this essay, I plan to discuss what I have learnt from him in terms of corporate management.

But before we discuss that, let me backtrack a bit and share with you where I come from. I am a non-resident Indian, practising in the US and managing a large medical group practice. Over the last 25 years, I have successfully helped incubate six multimillion-dollar businesses in health care, technology, and real estate. But nothing remotely comparable to the vast and complex operations he has managed... 

For any successful initiative in any organisation, the most critical step is the statement of the goal, no matter how difficult reaching it may appear. And this is not the first time. PM Modi has repeatedly reduced enormous objectives into simple formulations. Swachh Bharat. Make in India. Digital India... The next learning: break the silos. This can happen only if everyone is aligned and there is communication. Without clear articulation, ideas will not be universally shared and accepted. - Pariksith Singh|Sep 27, 2026,

https://www.firstpost.com/opinion/the-modi-management-playbook-10-lessons-for-india-inc-14048640.html

Can we act wholeheartedly without being bound by results? @PariksithSingh helps us understand Bhagavad Gita 2.47, revealing the wisdom of कर्मयोग—dedicated action, detachment, and inner freedom. Watch youtu.be/tGokRc56rGM?si… @MakrandParanspe @AmazingVedas

https://x.com/sriaurobindochr/status/2104316901308481787

Are spiritual promises distracting us from true wisdom? @PariksithSingh unpacks Bhagavad Gita 2.42–43, exploring Vedic कर्मकाण्ड, मोह, ज्ञान & भक्ति beyond material rewards. Watch youtu.be/61Fl1GZ9Ru4?si… @MakrandParanspe @AmazingVedas

https://x.com/sriaurobindochr/status/2103908460006191489

The Mahabharata: What Is the Big Deal?

It is interesting that even those teaching about the Gita and Ramayana in universities and the experts have no clue about what dharma is

Just attended a session on the Gita at JLF Boulder CO as a panelist. I was astounded to hear one of the well known panelists call it just a fratricidal war, that is, a war between brothers. And he said that the Kauravas were not all that bad and the Pandavas had flaws too. Really! This is the caliber of our commentators and critics and translators! This is what you have learned and are teaching?

Mahabharata is the transition between one age to another. It was a war of dharma. Pandavas are not dharmic because they have good qualities but because they are aligned to the Divine, they are surrendered to something greater, purer and wider, and they are willing to learn and grow. While the Kauravas are motivated by ego, unwilling to change even when they know the Truth and choose to be narrow, limited, dark, unrighteous. This is the critical difference. Dharma is that which holds things together and it is an instrument of the Divine. It is the path of Light, bhadram, Wisdom and Immortality. This is the Vedic understanding and we must know that the Mahabharata was a fight for the establishment of dharma

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2104002935097278934

Vedic Unity and Western Duality

During a recent discussion on the Gita at Jaipur Literary Festival, Boulder CO, I suddenly realized that western thought is based on duality and separation between man and God while eastern darshana springs from seeing the two as one

The Veda begins with this powerful and intense Unity. There is no separation between the inner and outer, the personal and universal, the immanent and the transcendental. The Upanishads and the Gita proclaim it timelessly and tirelessly. Once we realize this the rest becomes easy. Our arts and poetry, science and math, politics and culture are all based on this essential unity, even if they lost their intensity at times in the last two millennia or so. But the Unity was recovered by one great teacher after another. Western thought may have been influenced by the Vedic paradigm at its inception but only partially it seems and that too was lost irrecoverably after Plato

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2104408127349162231

Physics, and science as a whole, attempts to paint an objective picture of reality. Consciousness, experience, and subjectivity are forcibly pushed out. Even where science is empirical, this empiricism rarely involves a consideration of human consciousness, but rather the readings of some mechanical measuring device. But phenomenologist of science Harald A. Wiltsche paints a different picture. Physics, even in the form of quantum mechanics, finds its origins in the phenomenology of human consciousness. These origins are inescapable, and to truly move forward, scientists must understand and embrace them. Tap the link to read more. iai.tv/articles/consc…

https://x.com/IAI_TV/status/2104262320197124171

Western philosophy spent most of its history trying to grasp the necessary structure of reality through thought alone. Then Kant showed that reason can't reach the world without experience, and metaphysics looked finished. Hegel is often accused of ignoring that lesson and retreating into pre-Kantian speculation. Robert Pippin argues the opposite: Hegel took Kant's argument further. Reason may not be able to know the world, but it can know itself, and in uncovering the structure of thought, we uncover the structure of anything that can be thought at all. Read the full article here. iai.tv/articles/the-r…

https://x.com/IAI_TV/status/2104164193385468196

The oldest problem of democracy is how do we come to agreement about the 'facts'. We now live in a world where scientists are unable to agree on the nature of reality, and the proving grounds of politics are infected with fake news, deep fakes, and a decline of the institutions meant to keep them in check. Journalist Narain Batra argues, looking at the US example, we are entering a world of epistemic fragmentation where the silos of the internet have entered the real, physical world. A return to a stoic rejection of sophistry is the only way out. Tap the link now to read more: iai.tv/articles/truth…

https://x.com/IAI_TV/status/2103552668857684201

Faith: The Space We Leave Open for Mystery by Rajshekhar Pant countercurrents.org/2026/09/faith-…

In “Faith: The Space We Leave Open for Mystery,” Rajshekhar Pant reflects on faith, belief, reason and the limits of scientific proof. He distinguishes belief, which may rely on reason, experience or evidence, from faith, which involves a deeper trust in a person, idea, value or power. Drawing on research into spirituality and neuroscience, Pant considers how spiritual experiences may help organise the mind during uncertainty and stress, while acknowledging that science cannot establish the existence of God. He argues that faith can allow people to live with unanswered questions, preserving a sense of wonder, meaning, anticipation and mystery.

https://x.com/Countercurrents/status/2104431130053320956

On 2nd Feb 1786, a British judge in Calcutta named William Jones, who had co-founded the Asiatick Society himself, delivered his 3rd Anniversary Discourse, "On the Hindus," and made an observation now treated as the conventional public starting point of comparative linguistics in Europe... He went on, in that same sentence, to suggest Gothic, Celtic, and Old Persian likely belonged to this same family too, a remarkably prescient guess for 1786.

https://x.com/Fintech03/status/2104196642593440004

Remembering Kishan Patnaik: The Intellectual Quest for an Alternative Civilization by Dr Prem Singh countercurrents.org/2026/09/rememb…

On Kishan Patnaik’s 22nd death anniversary, this article revisits his critique of modern civilisation, technology, development and the role of the intelligentsia. Patnaik argued that intellectuals have a responsibility to help society understand its problems and that the condition of marginalised people must remain central to any assessment of development. His writings examined intellectual subordination, economic inequality, globalisation and the influence of market forces on journalism, education and public thought. He also explored the need for indigenous thinking and alternative approaches to civilisation. The article draws extensively on his writings, particularly his reflections on society, intellectual responsibility and the search for alternatives.

https://x.com/Countercurrents/status/2104405561668432184

In 1884, in the small town of Ballia, Father of Modern Hindi Literature, Bharatendu Harishchandra, rose to answer "How Can Bharatvarsh Progress?" and refused every excuse his listeners might have reached for. "Dharma is the root of every kind of progress, so Dharma should be reformed first." Bharatendu Harishchandra called for stripping away the customs that no longer serve, keeping only what genuinely helps society, and reform from within rather than waiting for anyone else to do it. Arjun Anand (@arjunanand3535), early career researcher with a Doctorate degree from Jawaharlal Nehru University, translates his landmark lecture in full. jungindien.in/blog/how- can-b…

https://x.com/JungIndien/status/2104215175054454878

A wonderful tribute to the man who played a key role in many nationalist and cultural projects of mid 20th century Madras. The troika of Rajaji - Kalki Krishnamurthi - Sadasivam were - contrary to caricatures - reformists by conviction. Excellent piece by @CranksCorner swarajyamag.com/culture/t-sada…

https://x.com/amargov/status/2104228707372249442

Today is the birth centenary of P.R. Brahmananda. He (with C.N. Vakil) offered an alternative to the Mahalanobis growth strategy in 1950s, was an influential monetary economist and a pillar of the Mumbai School of Economics, my alma mater More here: azimpremjiuniversity.edu.in/indian-economi…

https://x.com/CafeEconomics/status/2104173099700871262

The Enemy Within: Why Women Subconsciously Absorb and Weaponise Misogyny by Tehzeeb Anis countercurrents.org/2026/09/the-en…

Tehzeeb Anis examines how women can internalize patriarchal attitudes and reproduce them by policing, judging and blaming other women. Drawing on the example of victim-blaming after the Jamui harassment incident, the article explores how cultural conditioning, double standards and the pressure to conform can produce lateral hostility. It looks at manifestations including the policing of women’s clothing and choices, the “Queen Bee” phenomenon and the pursuit of male approval through the “Pick-Me” dynamic. The article argues that confronting internalized misogyny requires self-awareness, compassion and solidarity, moving away from rivalry and toward supportive relationships among women.

https://x.com/Countercurrents/status/2104416026322665539

Moral emotions are not natural defaults. Love, truth, respect, guilt, compassion and self-restraint are civilizational achievements, developed over centuries through reason, conscience and moral discipline. My latest essay:

https://x.com/JayantBhandari5/status/2100295150903636214

SELF - Savitri Era Party: Benefits of modernity that the missionary movement brought to India https://savitrieraparty.blogspot.com/2026/09/benefits-of-modernity-that-missionary.html

SELF - Savitri Era Political Action: Knowledge in fragments, fragmented syntax https://sepact.blogspot.com/2026/09/knowledge-in-fragments-fragmented-syntax.html

SELF - Savitri Era Religious Fraternity: Where Sri Aurobindo and Hayek meet https://serfrat.blogspot.com/2026/09/where-sri-aurobindo-and-hayek-meet.html 

SELF - VIP VAK: Akbar invited Portuguese Jesuits from Goa https://vipvak.blogspot.com/2026/09/akbar-invited-portuguese-jesuits-from.html

SELF - Aurora Mirabilis: Sri Aurobindo did not mean that everything is already perfect https://auroramirabilis.blogspot.com/2026/09/sri-aurobindo-did-not-mean-that.html

SELF - Because Thou Art: What constitutes a mental act? https://becausethouart.blogspot.com/2026/09/what-constitutes-mental-act.html

SELF - Evergreen Essays: Genes and the genius https://evergreenessays.blogspot.com/2026/09/genes-and-genius.html

SELF - Feel Philosophy: Auroville is the melting pot https://feelphilosophy.blogspot.com/2026/09/auroville-is-melting-pot.html

Savitri Era: My life as ideology https://savitriera.blogspot.com/2026/09/my-life-as-ideology.html  

Reimagining and Refashioning Integral Management

TN Mohapatra - Nitte Management Review, 2015 - scholar.archive.org
… modern civilization, Sri Aurobindo’s ontological formulations … This paper uses select concepts from Sri Aurobindo’s philosophy … beings as emphasised by Levinas or Habermas should also …

Hematologies: The Political Life of Blood in India: by Jacob Copeman and Dwaipayan Banerjee, London: Cornell University Press, 2019, pp. 1–288. Price: $27.95 …

R Rajakumaran, M Hashemi - 2025
… For example, Chapter two (“Sovereignty and Blood”) traces the evolution of
Gandhian hemo-politics versus that of contemporary Hindutva politics. Gandhi’s
willingness to shed or purify his blood was meant to demonstrate universal …

[HTML] Theorizing Historiographical Islamophobia

M Ward - Islamophobia Studies Journal, 2025
… Defined in this way, the verb “to classicize” offers us an action that we can see
being carried out by various agents (China, Israel and Hindutva India in the
examples discussed here—though we will see later in this article that classicism is …

[PDF] Conflating Democracy and Authoritarianism: Revisiting Populism in Pakistan

K Hussain - 2025
… The variant of populism prevalent in South Asia—especially in Pakistan, India
and Afghanistan—define “the people” in terms of their faith denominations as they
belong to a particular radically interpreted religious faith (Sunni Islam and Hindutva) …

[HTML] Lanzillo, Amanda. 2024. Pious Labor: Islam, Artisanship, and Technology in Colonial India

A Ahmed - 2025
Amanda Lanzillo 1 shows how Muslim artisans challenged and negotiated colonial
capitalism and social hierarchies in urban North India. Lanzillo argues that Muslim
artisans drew on the narratives of “laboring Islamic pasts” and “distinctively Muslim …

[HTML] Inclusion Discourse Amidst Changing Notions of the 'Idea of India' Ambedkar's Legacy a nd its Relevance Today

AK Gupta - Journal of Contemporary Politics
… While a group of educated Dalits have started raising their voice against Hindutva
worldview, claiming that in Hundutva scheme of things they … ’s legacy; and so-called
onslaught of Hindutva. There could be no denying the fact that the atrocities on …

[PDF] Reclaiming" Othered" Epistemologies: Dalit Perspectives in Postcolonial Scholarship

H Singh - INTER-The Journal for Global Thought, 2025
This research delves into the intricate dynamics of the concept of subalterns within
Postcolonial scholarship, mainly focusing on contributions from South Asian
academia. It critically addresses the marginalisation of resurgent epistemologies …

[PDF] The Unbecoming Ghost: Spectropolitics in the Making and Unmaking of BHU's Bhoot Vidya Ayurveda Certificate Program

T Seibel - Anthropology of Consciousness, 2025
This essay examines the controversy surrounding the Bhoot Vidya certificate
program proposed by the Faculty of Ayurveda at Banaras Hindu University in 2019.
Drawing on media coverage, curricular materials, and government policy, I analyze …

Bangalore Girls: Witnessing the Rise of Nationalism in a Progressive City by Supriya Baily

RR Subramanian - 2025
… In the shadow of the Babri Masjid demolition, in the rise of Hindutva, in the slow
encroachment of suspicion and self-censorship. The same women who once felt at
ease in the city’s public spaces now measure their safety, their wardrobe, even their …

Cultural Identity in Hindi Plays: Poetics, Politics, and Theatre in India by Diana Dimitrova

S Chakrabarti - Journal of Dramatic Theory and Criticism, 2025
… In order to establish the dominance of hindutva-leaning sentiments that Dimitrova
ultimately associates with mythologizing the past, she focuses on media
representations, especially "popular Indian cinema" that reinforce "the self-effacing …

Understanding Propaganda: A Study of Media in Contemporary India

A Basu
… Set up in 1985, it has produced over one hundred political videos related to
Parliamentary and Assembly elections in India as well as issuebased videos on
campaigns and other events organized and staged for the purpose of mobilizing …

Wednesday, September 23, 2026

The shoe doesn’t fit

 Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra

Just released Veda for Gen Z at JLF, Boulder CO instagram.com/stories/jlfint… 

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2102540707873558576

The Literary Genius of the Bhagavad Gita

The Gita follows the literary tradition of the Veda. It uses the seed sounds and plays with Nirukta, the mantrik intonation of its shlokas has the same approach to a vibrational backdrop of sound, but there is no Siksa or Vedic chanting here. The chhanda too is only anushtup or trishtup in the Gita

The Gita is designed in a kaleidoscopic manner too like the Veda but by necessity it has to deliver a clear and pragmatic message while allowing the disciple enough consideration and space to gain a larger outlook for life and his actions

While being Vedic in niyojana and substance, the Gita nonetheless creates its own tropes. The most powerful among them, though hidden, is the visual sleight; we see the whole episode through the eyes of Sanjaya and that changes the whole psychology of the story

And yet, the Gita gives us the essence of the Veda in its shorter span and compact dialogic pedagogic engagement. It is, in its own place, a masterpiece of literature and art though Vedic Vedantic in lineage

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2101319830108283176

The Literary Genius of the Bhagavad Gita: The Meta Narrative

Imagine a work of literature which is full of action, exciting characters, an epic scale and enormous stakes and the author suddenly stops all action right at the edge of a most cataclysmic moment to sit back and meditate! What would you think? That would be absurd, right!

Well, the Gita pulls it off with flair. In fact, so well does it accomplish this as literature that there are few works in the history of mankind that have had such an impact

The most curious thing is that narrative collapses completely for those 700 shlokas. And yet, without the Gita, the Mahabharata itself would be of minor significance

How was this made possible? Some commentators theorize that the Gita was inserted into the epic later. It doesn’t matter! If it was then this was the greatest interpolation in the history of world literature. If it wasn’t this was the greatest meta narrative freezing a narrative as it is beginning to build up into a seismic event. Either way it is a masterly trope in one of the greatest epics in world literature that we accept as a fact, a reality, accessible even today in its spiritual realization

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2102256752246825180

A Literary Approach to the Veda

Why a literary approach? Because it allows me complete freedom. It seems to me that at present there are two kinds of tyranny blocking the fullest or most open appreciation of the Veda. 

The first is the western tendency or insistence to take the Veda as only external ritual. And to restrict it from the thousands of years of living traditions of interpretation and experience that it has meant for the Indigenous cultures

The second is the Indic insistence again to see it as karma kanda only. To be fair, this insistence is not universal nor as closed as the west. And the multiple meanings of the Veda can be unveiled, in my experience, more easily in India than in the west. For India is still in touch with its spirituality in many forms including the Upanishads which are a part of the Veda

Great teachers have valiantly tried in the last 150 years or so to bring out the multiple dimensions of the Veda. A literary approach allows me to consider all the various commentaries and interpretations of the Veda and to present them to the world and let the reader consider them independently and decide on their own. I am even allowed to present my own thoughts without any attempt to hide them. I have attempted the same with the Bhagavad Gita and found that a multidimensional approach to the Gita was critical to my own development. I find the same with the Veda

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2097648893227860083

Vedic Sahitya

What are the grand literary achievements of the Veda?

1) The first exploration of seed sounds or Beeja Dhvanis in literature

2) The use of the mantra as the basis for meter

3) The unique holographic organization of verse along with the designing of experience

4) A theory of cosmology, sound, prosody and linguistics in action and explanation

5) Unique experiments and figures of speech that still feel modern and fresh

6) The establishment of the bases of meter such as accent, stress, quantity etc and combining them in the enunciation, an experiment that has not been repeated since

7) The use of the most sophisticated human alphabet and grammar to date 

Feel free to add more please if I missed any

Veda is not our first poetry. It is the first poetry we have. How were they created remains a mystery? Historical explanations don’t suffice. In no other human field do we see this. An appearance of perfection at the very inception of the field. How? Why? We don’t really know. 

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2101284690426486824

Vedic Chhanda: Holograms 

Because the Veda is composed of units that are independent, complete, organic, and self sufficient, we can take any section of the Veda and discover the Poornam there

This wholeness is not just a wholeness of sound or prosody but it is also a complete formation of energy, meaning, realization and experience 

We can move backward and forward, or in other complex patterns. The purnata of each section remains and moves in sync as a kaleidoscope even as the permutations are changed

Thus, the various paathas of the Veda are not just exercises in memory but a combination of various meanings and experiences in different orders, resetting the consciousness of the seeker in new ways. We will experiment with the two anuvakas here to see how we can touch spirituality at any point, in any order

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2100446733482242100

Vedic Chhanda: The Mantra

The Mantra, to paraphrase Sri Aurobindo, is the highest perfection, poornta, of Vision, Style and Rhythm. It is the music that rises beyond the words and reverberates through the Universe.

That which liberates through meditation is mantra मननात् त्रायते इति मंत्र:

But there is more. The mantra can transform not just the mind but also the praana and the body. For it is alchemic, a process of heightened energy and resonance

But most seekers do not know how to unleash its power. When chanting the mantra remember these fundamentals: श्रद्धा, भाव, ध्यान, ग्राह्य क्षमता, समर्पण 

The whole being must be laser sharp in reciting it, pronunciation must be clear, exact, smooth and melodious, and one must allow the vibration to become one’s DNA. Then something might happen. In the meantime listen quietly to the sound behind the sound, the string that reverberates from worlds hidden to your inmost depths

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2099297947275997324

Vedic Matrix

The entire Veda and the Bhagavad Gita may be seen as a matrix of seed sounds. Suddenly, their prosody assumes a musical and mathematical substructure with this perspective

We have seen how the music of these masterly creations is a play of Varna, svara, bala, matra, sandhi and Sanatana. Each Chhanda brings in elements of upward and downward movements that we later see in music (आरोह and अवरोह), each chhanda plays within its own restrictions or बंदिश, and other elements such as आलाप and तान too are hinted here 

Mathematically, I believe, the possibilities created by Vedic have not been fully exhausted but that remains a subject of future research and exploration. The great accomplishments of Pingala may yet be extended with a better understanding of seed sounds and their matrix

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2098340033899970711

Vedic History

I am not a historian. But I know literature

This is clear to me, and I believe to most historians, that the Veda is great literature

And this is where the contradiction appears

If the Veda is great literature then it must have come out of a living tradition. For it is extremely sophisticated and refined in its use of language. The Veda couldn’t have appeared out of nowhere

Remember, according to our present textbooks, the Veda is our first poetry. Those of us who write know that a great literature stands on a living culture and civilization. That would mean that our timeline of the Veda is extremely restricted. Nomadic traditions could not have created the Veda

Then the language. Vedic is a highly advanced language with an alphabet and inherent linguistics that too must have taken centuries or millennia to develop

Our present history has not a serious understanding of great literature, art or spirituality. Veda is not AI. It can’t be churned out to order

So, history contradicts itself. The present timeline has an inherent flaw. It doesn’t account for its own greatest achievements

Whom should I believe? My own testimony or their word? The shoe doesn’t fit 

And I have tried to write this without any bias for the Indic culture which I adore. Feel free to critique 

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2098756402873250278

Vedic Concept: Bandhu

This is one of the most important aspects of Vedic worldview. The bandhu is a kinsman, friend, brother, someone who is related

In the Vedic paradigm everything is related to the other intimately. And this close connection is inherent and not dependent on any external factor

The term bandhu appears in the Veda in RV 6.57.4, 7.67.9 and 10.10.9. And it becomes clarified in the Vedantic and Buddhist concepts of Pratitya Samutpada

All the devas are related to each other in the unity of Vishvedeva and Ritam, Satyam and in the Vast expanse of the Universe, Brihat. All the fields and disciplines are connected in one vast realization of Ekam Sat

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2098188077558558775

Kashmir Shaivism: Prakaasah Prakaasate 

Great realizations are described in the most concentrated manner here

How can this sutra even be translated! Any attempt will be a failure!

The Light Reflects 

Or 

The Light Enlightens 

Or

The Radiance Radiates

Each translation is limited because the self-awareness and vimarsha are an integral part of this sutra. Vast, comprehensive and nondual, what a powerful revelation of Shiva from one of the greatest polymaths of all time, Abhinavagupta! Simply brilliant! 

https://x.com/AmazingVedas/status/2099724777766224369

The structure of this verse is significant. It first invokes the welfare of society, then righteous governance according to justice, and thereafter the protection of cows and Brahmanas—symbols within the Hindu civilisational framework representing sustenance, sacred learning, preservation of Vedic knowledge, and continuity of dharmic institutions. Only after invoking these conditions does the verse conclude with the aspiration that all worlds or beings may be happy.

Universal well-being is therefore not presented as an isolated sentimental ideal detached from Hindu religious order. Rather, it is presented as the natural consequence of a society governed according to Sanātana Dharma and sustained by institutions that preserve Hindu religious and civilisational continuity.

Therefore, Hindu universalism is fundamentally dharmic rather than indiscriminate. These prayers express the aspiration that the order of Sanātana Dharma should prevail widely so that human beings may live ethically, recognise what is righteous, and reduce suffering. Consequently, they cannot be interpreted as affirming religions, doctrines, forces, or systems that reject, attack, or seek to destroy Sanātana Dharma itself, for a prayer seeking the flourishing of dharma cannot simultaneously affirm its negation.

https://x.com/MNageswarRaoIPS/status/2100775518253822464

Should Shiva Need Schrodinger?

Dr. Mrittunjoy Guha Majumdar's "From Shiva to Schrodinger: Unravelling Cosmic Secrets with Trika Shaivism & Quantum Insights" belongs to a growing body of literature that seeks to place Hindu philosophy in conversation with modern physics, particularly quantum mechanics. The author seeks to place a metaphysical tradition in dialogue with a scientific theory by exploring their apparent convergences on questions of consciousness, reality and non-duality.

To his credit, the author is aware of the methodological difficulties involved. Chapter 15 explicitly recognises that Trika Shaivism and quantum mechanics arise from different historical, cultural and epistemological contexts. He cautions against reductionism, superficial analogies and conceptual misrepresentation, urging readers to respect the integrity of both traditions and to seek common themes rather than direct equivalences. These qualifications are thoughtful and philosophically responsible.

Yet the book simultaneously aspires to "bridge spirituality and physics." The Chapter 11 title Quantrika itself symbolically fuses quantum mechanics and Trika Shaivism into a single conceptual enterprise. Throughout the later chapters, parallels accumulate between quantum concepts and Trika metaphysics. The difficulty is not that such comparisons are attempted. The problem is that the book never explains why such comparisons are epistemically necessary.

Physics empirically investigates the physical world through observation, experiment and mathematical theory. Trika Shaivism experientially explores consciousness, ultimate reality and liberation through its own pramāṇas and metaphysical disciplines. They ask different questions, pursue different ends and justify their conclusions differently. Before attempting to bridge these domains, one must first explain why such a bridge is philosophically required. What deficiency in physics is completed by Trika Shaivism? Conversely, what deficiency in Trika Shaivism requires confirmation from quantum mechanics? The book assumes the desirability of integration without first establishing its necessity.

This omission has important consequences. If the proposed parallels are merely illustrative, they neither strengthen nor weaken the truth of either discipline. They remain intellectually interesting but establish nothing about the truth of either. If, however, they are intended to establish a deeper convergence or lend credibility to Trika metaphysics through modern physics, then the project tacitly elevates empirical science into the final authority on religious truth. The question then becomes unavoidable: why should a religious tradition seek validation through an empirical science?

The implications are more serious than they first appear. A tradition that claims independent pramāṇas, a sophisticated metaphysics and millennia of philosophical reflection should not require external certification from a discipline investigating a different order of reality. If scientific compatibility becomes the criterion of legitimacy, then the final epistemic authority quietly shifts from Vyasa, Sankara and Abhinavagupta to Planck, Schrodinger and Heisenberg. In attempting to defend Sanātana Dharma, the project inadvertently places it before the tribunal of modern science. Far from strengthening the tradition, it compromises its epistemic independence.

Indeed, the argument leads to an uncomfortable reductio ad absurdum. If the credibility of Trika Shaivism ultimately depends upon its compatibility with quantum mechanics, then quantum mechanics—not Trika Shaivism—becomes the decisive source of epistemic authority. Once scientific validation becomes the criterion of legitimacy, the independent authority of the religious tradition is no longer primary but derivative. The very attempt to defend the religion thus risks subordinating it to the discipline from which it seeks validation.

The philosophical difficulty is compounded by a series of category errors. Similarity is not identity; resonance is not evidence; analogy is not confirmation. The non-duality of Brahman is not the equivalence of mass and energy. One is a metaphysical claim concerning the ontological ground of existence; the other is a scientific claim concerning measurable physical entities. Their shared language of "unity" does not establish conceptual equivalence. The same methodological difficulty recurs throughout the book whenever quantum concepts are juxtaposed with Trika metaphysical concepts. Because the comparisons remain merely analogical, the result is that superficial resemblance is mistaken for conceptual equivalence.

Ironically, the very religious tradition invoked throughout the book offers the resources to resist this confusion. Hindu philosophy consistently emphasises viveka—the disciplined discrimination between distinct pramāṇas, distinct levels of reality and distinct domains of inquiry. The enthusiasm to discover modern physics within Sanātana Dharma risks dissolving precisely those distinctions. In seeking common ground, the book blurs the very boundaries it rightly urges us to preserve.

These observations extend beyond this particular volume. They point to a broader intellectual tendency within modern Hindu writing that seeks scientific legitimacy for ancient metaphysical doctrines and religious traditions. Works such as "Maya in Physics" by Dr. N. C. Panda, together with numerous books and popular lectures drawing parallels between quantum mechanics and Vedanta, Yoga or Tantra, illustrate the persistence of this apologetic impulse. The issue, therefore, is not this book alone but the philosophical assumption underlying an entire genre: that Hindu religious truth becomes more credible when it resembles contemporary science. Yet science and religion are not rival claimants to the same territory. They belong to different epistemic orders and pursue different purposes. Neither requires the other for its legitimacy.

The search for scientific validation neither strengthens Sanātana Dharma nor enriches science. It obscures the distinction between two fundamentally different orders of inquiry: religion and science. Each has its own methods, standards of truth, epistemic foundations and purposes. Neither requires the other's endorsement.

https://x.com/MNageswarRaoIPS/status/2078128238929527143

Meera Nanda makes a similar argument for why the indian left let hindufascists appropriate and champion postmodernist woo among the left; they were marxists that didn't think ideas could change material and political conditions, so the stakes of bad discourse or rhetoric among the left was nil.

https://bsky.app/profile/rechelon.bsky.social/post/3lw2qo2wa4s2r

Oh yeah, Meera Nanda is big on explaining which Western pomo leftie academics were sucked in to affirming Hindutva nonsense

https://bsky.app/profile/daphnelawless.com/post/3m4capbczyc27

Book review: When Postcolonial Left and the Hindu Right turned bedfellows

It was said about Bertrand Russell that it was impossible to paraphrase his prose; it was so precise and succinct. This is true of Meera Nanda, too... 

A distinctive Hindu sensibility is innate in the political unconscious of Indian postcolonial theorists. The gods they invoke, the mythic mode they use to understand history, and the holistic modes of knowing they speak about are all Hindu... 

Together, they take the reader through every corner of the philosophy of science and sociology of knowledge, apart from probing relevant ideas in the political and ideological areas of thought. This book is even more elaborate than her solid Prophets Facing Backward (2006). All her other books are slim, but substantial in terms of content. So much has passed since the publication of Prophets that this book had to be thicker and contain her views on the innumerable ideas that have cropped up in the areas she focuses on. 

The quarter century since that book was published has been turbulent and Nanda has been alert to every development since, both the gross and the subtle. The main story is about the coming together of two apparently incompatible groups, the Postcolonial Left and the Hindu Right. 

https://www.thenewsminute.com/news/book-review-when-postcolonial-left-and-the-hindu-right-turned-bedfellows

Some more gems follow—here, Nanda takes up her cudgel against Partha Chatterjee's "Nationalist Thought and the Colonial World: A Derivative Discourse?" (Zed for the United Nations University; 1986). This is the most bizarre stuff I have read in a really long time. (10/n)

https://x.com/PhilipPanass/status/2015486519776260457

Absolutely. I am v embarassed about the bullcrap I wrote about "scientific absolutes" and what not, when I didn't in fact have any understanding of quantum physics or the advances in modern biology or, you know, maths.

https://x.com/swatiatrest/status/2016121738955010213

SELF - Evergreen Essays: Perfection at the very inception https://evergreenessays.blogspot.com/2026/09/perfection-at-very-inception.html

SELF - Because Thou Art: And then the clarity poured in https://becausethouart.blogspot.com/2026/09/and-then-clarity-poured-in.html

23 hours ago — In the 1950s, the writings of Indian gurus like Sri Aurobindo found their way into America and the American Academy of Asian Studies was founded in 1951.

Michael J. Altman's book review of American Veda: From Emerson and the Beatles to Yoga and Meditation, How Indian Spirituality Changed the West by Philip Goldberg (Harmony Books, 2010)

Meanwhile, American culture has its own history of mystical, esoteric, and spiritual resources. While Theosophists, Christian Scientists, Transcendentalists, and New Thoughters were influenced by Vedic texts, they were also part of a long Western tradition of esotericism and metaphysics. Emmanuel Swedenborg and Franz Anton Mesmer had has much if not more influence on these groups as Vedic texts. The “spiritual East comes to the material West” narrative is powerful but it is over-simple.

https://iskconnews.org/bn/why-theres-yoga-at-your-church-or-synagogue-or-mosque-or/

SELF - Aurora Mirabilis: Emanuel Swedenborg, Franz Anton Mesmer, and Frederic W. H. Myers https://auroramirabilis.blogspot.com/2026/09/emanuel-swedenborg-franz-anton-mesmer.html

SELF - VIP VAK: She’s the cleaning lady https://vipvak.blogspot.com/2026/09/shes-cleaning-lady.html

Thursday, September 17, 2026

Triggering a stimulus

 The shift of "rent-seeking" and "entitlement" from neutral terms into heavily pejorative terms happened through two entirely different paths—one born in academic economics and the other in American political and psychological shifts.

Here is how each term became a pejorative:

1. Rent-Seeking: Gordon Tullock and Anne Krueger

In economics, "rent" historically referred simply to income derived from ownership (like land) rather than labor. It wasn't inherently an insult.
  • The Concept: Economist Gordon Tullock first outlined the concept in 1967. He argued that when companies spend money to lobby the government for special privileges—like tariffs or monopolies—it wastes society's resources. [1, 2]
  • The Pejorative Label: Economist Anne Krueger officially coined and popularized the exact phrase "rent-seeking" in her influential 1974 paper, "The Political Economy of the Rent-Seeking Society". [1, 3]
  • Why it is a pejorative: Krueger and Tullock used it to describe a drain on the economy. By definition, rent-seeking is now a negative term used to describe individuals or corporations who manipulate political systems to secure wealth without creating any new value or doing productive work. [4, 5, 6]

2. Entitlement: The Shift from a Legal Right to an Insult

Originally, "entitlement" was a purely neutral legal and political term. In 1945, it was used to describe the G.I. Bill, and in the 1960s, President Lyndon B. Johnson used it proudly to describe Medicare, meaning citizens had a rightful, earned claim to it. [7, 8]
The weaponization of the word happened through two fronts:
FrontWho Made It PejorativeHow the Meaning Shifted
PsychologyRobert Coles & Narcissism Researchers (1970s)Child psychiatrist Robert Coles studied the "children of affluence" and popularized "entitlement" as a psychological flaw—describing wealthy, spoiled children who believed they deserved special treatment without working for it.
PoliticsConservative Strategists (Reagan Era / 1980s)Opponents of the welfare state intentionally dropped the word "earned" from government programs. By calling welfare, Social Security, and food stamps "entitlements," they subtly shifted the definition from a "legal right" to a "demand made by lazy or greedy freeloaders".
By the 1990s and 2000s, these two streams fused. Today, calling someone "entitled" or labeling a government budget an "entitlement" is almost exclusively used as a disparaging shorthand for unjustified privilege, arrogance, or spoiled behavior. [9, 10]

If you want to dive deeper, would you like to explore how economists measure the financial damage of rent-seeking, or look into other political terms that underwent a similar linguistic shift?

- GoogleAI
No, "stimulus" is not losing ground to "trigger" globally, but they are undergoing a massive shift in cultural territory. While "stimulus" remains dominant in formal, institutional, and macroeconomic contexts, "trigger" has completely overtaken it in everyday social, psychological, and online speech. [1, 2]
The intersection of these two words comes down to a shift in how we describe cause and effect:

1. The Broadening of "Trigger"

Originally confined to firearms, mechanics, and specific clinical psychology terms (e.g., a "trauma trigger"), "trigger" has undergone massive semantic bleaching. It has evolved into a casual catch-all verb and noun meaning "to cause an immediate reaction" or "an emotional spark". [1, 3, 4]
  • In everyday slang: People routinely say "That song triggered a memory" instead of "That song acted as a stimulus for a memory."
  • In tech and business: Systems rely on automated triggers (e.g., "an email trigger"), not "stimuli." [1, 5]

2. The Specialization of "Stimulus"

"Stimulus" has not disappeared, but it has retreated into specialized, high-level domains where "trigger" doesn't quite fit:
  • Economics: Governments issue economic stimulus packages. Referring to it as a "trigger package" would change the meaning entirely.
  • Hard Sciences: In biology, neuroscience, and physiology, organisms still respond to external stimuli. However, even within science, textbooks often note that a stimulus is the agent that triggers a response. [6, 7, 8, 9, 10]

Direct Comparison

AttributeStimulusTrigger
Primary DomainEconomics, Biology, Academic PsychologyEveryday Speech, Technology, Pop Psychology
ConnotationNourishing or activating: Implies a spark meant to encourage growth or a mechanical sensory input.Sudden or disruptive: Implies an immediate, often involuntary or emotional chain reaction.
Plural/Verb UsageClunky plural (stimuli); rarely used as a natural verb ("to stimulate" has different connotations).Highly adaptive (trigger, triggers, triggering, triggered).
Ultimately, "stimulus" is holding its ground in formal writing, but "trigger" has won the battle for modern vernacular because it is highly flexible, functions seamlessly as a verb, and aligns with society's heavy focus on fast-acting, electronic, and emotional cause-and-effect. [1, 2]
Are you analyzing this for a creative writing project, looking at linguistic trends, or drafting a psychology/business text? Let me know, and I can help you choose the best word for your context.

- GoogleAI 
Modern psychology and neuroscience largely disagree with Sri Aurobindo’s Integral Yoga on the fundamental source and nature of consciousness. [1]

Nature of Consciousness

  • Modern Science: Neuroscience views consciousness as a byproduct or emergent property of physical brain activity and neural networks.
  • Sri Aurobindo: Integral Yoga treats consciousness as the fundamental reality of existence—universal and self-luminous—rather than a mere product of matter. [1]

Structure of the Mind and Subconscious

  • Modern Science: Western psychology (such as Freudian and Jungian models) maps the mind through surface consciousness, the personal unconscious, and collective archetypes, often blending deeper subtle realms together. [2]
  • Sri Aurobindo: Integral Yoga draws a fine-grained map distinguishing the subconscient (the raw storehouse of primitive and repressed reactions) from the subliminal (a vast, luminous inner consciousness behind the surface). It further maps ascending planes above the ordinary mind (Higher Mind, Overmind, Supermind). [2, 3, 4]

Evolutionary Scope

  • Modern Science: Evolutionary biology and psychology explain human development through physical adaptation and natural selection.
  • Sri Aurobindo: He proposed a spiritual evolution driven by divine "involution," where consciousness progressively manifests from matter to life, mind, and ultimately an inevitable transition to the Supermind. [5]
If you'd like to explore further, let me know if you want to focus on:
  • How transpersonal psychology bridges some of these gaps
  • Specific therapeutic applications of inner awareness

It is not hard to see ourselves in them — how much of our essential character dwells beneath the surface of the self, how seemingly similar people may differ profoundly in their subterranean essence. It helps to remember that the visible self is fed by an invisible counterpart at least as intricate and extensive; that the two are so tightly stemmed together that we are always interacting with both the visible person and their invisible root system.

Moral emotions are not natural defaults. Love, truth, respect, guilt, compassion and self-restraint are civilizational achievements, developed over centuries through reason, conscience and moral discipline. My latest essay:
[In their higher meanings, love requires concern for the other person’s welfare. Compassion requires recognition of another’s suffering as morally real. Respect requires recognition of dignity. Peace requires inner integration and trust. Truthfulness requires loyalty to reality even when the consequences are painful. None of these higher meanings is instinctive. Left to nature, man is governed by appetite, fear, status, sex, possession, resentment, vanity, and power. Civilization exists precisely to discipline these instincts and transform them into virtues.] 

Happy Birthday Modiji, the most vain, narcissistic, megalomanic, paranoid, and absolute reneger and forsworn Prime Minister ever in the history and future of India. I wish you well, but I love my country and countrymen more. So, when you gain insight, please leave.

May Ma Meenakshi Annai and Lord Sundareshwarar whose temple in Madurai is also seeing its Maha Kumbabishekam today shower their blessings on our dear PM @narendramodi ji and his able leadership continue for as long a time as necessary for India. Happy Birthday Modi ji.

What are the odds of the hotel owner talking to me on his breakfast rounds and I tell him how the Aurobindo ashram made me uncomfortable when I last visited and his family turn out to be hardcore ashramites

Most Tamil Brahmins have photos of Aurobondo and "Mother" in their home, in addition to Jiddu Krishnamurti. At least the Hip modern ones. Actual Trads are a microminority. Rural primitivists and literalists rarely survive integration into modernity. Just 2 generations is enough
Interesting, I've never seen Aurobindo or Jiddu among Malayali Brahmins, UC-s or LC-s, except when they're urban and "raita".

The heroic act of extraordinary courage, loyalty and patriotism of Baji Prabho has been immortalised by Sri Aurobindo in his famous poem. I wish that poem is added to high school English language text books in Maharastra. @Dev_Fadnavis motherandsriaurobindo.in/Sri-Aurobindo/…

How can we act without being bound by the fruits of action? Explore the Gita’s profound insights into karma, detachment, self-knowledge and spiritual freedom. Join @PariksithSingh youtu.be/eoVn21bMqSA?si… @MakrandParanspe @AmazingVedas

Why does Krishna tell Arjuna not to grieve? Explore Gita 2.11 with Sri Aurobindo: wisdom begins when we see beyond grief, delusion and the transient to the deeper truth of the Self. Join @PariksithSingh youtu.be/u8m4OU8IFAg?si… @MakrandParanspe @AmazingVedas

THE TRANSNATIONALISATION OF STRATEGIC DIGITAL INFORMATION OPERATIONS

I Yilmaz, P Chacko, S de Groot Heupner, A Sreekumar - Authoritarian Actors and …, 2025
… Prior to the Indian elections in 2024, the websites or social media handles of
Hindutva hate crime tracker websites like Hindutva Watch as well as India Hate Lab
were blocked. The farmer’s protests in India have also led to the censorship of a …

FUTURE DIRECTIONS IN STRATEGIC DIGITAL INFORMATION OPERATIONS AND WARFARE

I Yilmaz - Authoritarian Actors and Strategic Digital Information …, 2025
This book has undertaken an extensive exploration of SDIOs, offering a novel
framework to understand and analyze the digital manipulation by state and nonstate
actors. The chapters collectively address the theoretical, methodological, and …

OTT services in India

N Bose - Routledge Handbook of South Asian Cinemas, 2025
… This, I argue, is at the center of the Hindutva discourse when it comes to cinema,
as well as SVOD content, including web series. The … Apart from this, we can
observe some degree of pro-Hindutva content on different platforms. In general, the …

Story, sound, and spectacle signifying everything

A Ram - Routledge Handbook of South Asian Cinemas, 2025
In 2023, the American Girl doll franchise owned by Mattel unveiled its first South
Asian doll-Kavi Sharma. The creative team behind the making of the doll included
multi-generational South Asians as advisors. Kavi is fictionally situated in Metheun …

The Names We Carry With Us

SV KRISHNAMURTI - South Asian Feminisms in Diaspora: Critical …, 2025
… I am in a group supporting Dalit scholars who are being harassed by Hindutva
groups. The strategy, as requested by the Dalit scholars themselves, is to specifically
approach those whose names are identifiably Hindu to sign a letter from “concerned …

The Dialogic of Praxis

D CHEW - South Asian Feminisms in Diaspora: Critical …, 2025
THIS CHAPTER EVOLVED from the keynote I gave at the Critical South Asian
Feminisms symposium, in July 2021, in what is now called Canada, northern Turtle
Island. 1 I am grateful and honoured to have been part of this rich and exciting …

[PDF] Cultural heritage a way to the past: exploring the cultural heritage in Anita Nair's novel The Better Man

J VG, JCR Gill - Cogent Arts & Humanities, 2025
Heritage, traditional values, and related cultural practices – tools to assess ancestral
lifestyles- are quintessential touchstones for human well-being. Heritage might be in
the form of cultural symbols such as buildings, monuments, artifacts, language, and …

[PDF] Artmaking As Intervention in Oral History Methodology: Painting Portraits of Queer/Trans South Asian Chosen Family

A Garg - 2025
… There is political significance here, “In this moment that we're seeing [the] rise of
like Hindutva, or Hindu fascism, I think there's something really beautiful in this
tradition that feels important to learn from, to highlight to people who, love this music …

[HTML] Inflammatory Propaganda and the Shadows of Partition: The Role of RSS's Organiser and HMS's Hindu Rashtra in 1947 Communal Violence

SSEO Tools
… The RSS and HMS, though ideologically aligned in Hindutva, diverged in
approach. RSS focused on grassroots mobilization, viewing media as a tool for
ideological indoctrination. Organiser—its first formal organ—blended editorials with …

Right-wing populists and noisy politics for big business

A Avigur-Eshel - Contemporary Politics, 2025
Right-wing populists harbour suspicion toward big business, so the literature finds.
Despite their general sympathy for private capital, they have been found to manifest
outright hostility toward big business or construct uneasy cooperation with it. Hostility …

Language Proficiency and Linguistic Citizenship: Rethinking Multilingual TESOL Through an Emotional Geography of Languages

A Ahmed - Multilingual TESOL: De-constructing and Re …, 2025
This chapter focuses on how a multilingual approach to TESOL has the potential to
rethink students’ language proficiency and linguistic citizenship. Through this
discussion, I show why developing students’ language proficiency alone—and …

Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra