Thursday, November 24, 2005
Hope and Tragedy: Two Faces of Indian Liberalism
A Modi come Jaitley
- Where is the spirit of social reform in today’s educated leaders, particularly those like Jaitley who are uniquely placed to lead the younger generation?
- Why are they instead proliferating a social conservatism by which Hindu ‘virtue’ is to be measured by yardsticks like glittering rituals, the thickness of sindoor and a bewildering denunciation of Muslims?
- Why will politicians like Jaitley not rise in Parliament and instead of banging on about the foreign threat to the Hindu rashtra make a speech on how young politicians like him are committed to an egalitarian society?
Jaitley will not make such a speech because his alter ego is Modi. Jaitley is economically progressive but socially conservative. Jaitley’s alliance with Narendra Modi is indicative of a cultural revolution let loose by the present ruling dispensation. This is a revolution by which the affluent and the educated have become anti-modern. A revolution by which it is fashionable to have a mind as narrow as your trousers.
- Ekta Kapoor wears tiger skin miniskirts but produces soap operas venerating women as Hindu doormats.
- Matrimonial advertisements for scholarly IIT graduates demand brides from specific castes.
- Mumbai, citadel of new India, has been a prisoner of the Shiv Sena for well over three decades.
- College graduates model high fashion clothes but prefer to have their marriages arranged by their parents.
- An Infosys employee in the US, supposedly on the cutting edge of economic modernity had to go under a cloud of sexual harassment.
In sharp contrast to Raja Rammohan Roy who used his education and his social privileges to reform society, Arun Jaitley is using his education to make Modi fashionable.
My Top Ten list for Rio+10
MOHAN DHARIA THE INDIAN EXPRESS Saturday, August 31, 2002
It’s expected that the Johannesburg summit will prescribe basic guidelines and a timebound plan of action for sustainable development. Here are ten of my suggestions: 1. Natural resources like land, water, air, forests and species belong to society. No individual or organisation should have a right to utilise these resources according to his or her desire. Society or the people should lay certain conditions over the use of the natural resources in resepective areas.
2. The luxury and pleasure oriented lifestyle must change. Instead, people should adopt the principle of ‘Moderate Living and High Thinking’. Renowned saints and seers all over the world have advocated the philosophy of ‘Simple Living and High Thinking for the past hundreds of years. Mahatma Gandhiji warned the world, long ago that ‘‘nature has enough potential to meet the geniune human need but it would never be possible to meet the ever growing greed.’’
3. It would be advisable to encourage decentralised production in order to preserve nature and ensure social justice. A decentralised economy and Decentralised authority are not only consistant with people’s democracy, but they’re equally ecofriendly and necessary for sustainable development.
4. The craze for unplanned urbanisation and race for mega cities should be immediately halted. Mega cities have created unhealthy filthy slums and pollution all over the world. No new city above a population above one million should be encouraged, and all cities with a one million plus population should be asked to commence decongestion by creating new growth centres.
This action will considerably help in bringing down the demand for water, wider roads, flyoers and markets, avoiding further pollution.
5. The backbone of rural life has been virtually broken by fast industrialisation, commercialisation and urbanisation. A better course would be to emphasise the process of decentralisation. It’s equally important to stop the influx of people migrating to cities in search of employment and other civic amenities.
6. All countries and cities creating abnormal levels of air, water and noise pollution should be asked to bring down their levels within permissible limits. Both rich and poor countries will have to play a positive role in this regard.
7. A concrete programme should be undertaken in all poor and developing countries to bring down the growth rate of population. Eradication of illiteracy, education and the health care of pregnant and lactating mothers alongwith newly born babies will have to be clubbed together to successfully implement the family planning programmes. Unless all countries agree to ensure employment or earning opportunities to every citizen, it would never be possible to improve the quality of life of the people.
8. Social and economic disparities have widened the valley between the rich and the poor. Though huge investments are necessary to create infrastructure for industrial and agricultural growth, the development of unused and underutilised natural resources like land, water and cattle wealth posseses tremendous potential to generate jobs and render social justice.
9. People the world over have been watching such international summits and conferences for years. They are rightly feel that most of the developed countries are only interested in exploiting developing countries as their markets. Rich nations should realise that enhancing the income level of millions of people in developing countries may be a sensible approach.
10. People the world over want positive action, particularly from rich countries. Mere expression of resolve is not adequate—what’s needed is urgent action, a complete change in attitude. Before people lose all faith, the Johannesburg summit should provide the required lead for sustainable development and a new world order. The writer, who heads the environmental organisation Vanarai, is a former MP, former Environment minister and former head of the Planning Commission. He is also a part of of the Indian delegation at the Johannesburg summit.
Wednesday, November 23, 2005
Health mustn’t hinge on wealth
- This then brings in the question of individual vulnerability which an Ambani and the rickshaw puller have in common, giving rise to the most fundamental principle — is profiteering on the sickness of other humans ethical?
- Can companies be lauded and individuals be rewarded the best entrepreneurial award for increasing profits on the ill health and vulnerability of people who are struck with the misfortune of falling sick?
Compared to the US, Canada provides universal health care of the same level of quality at one third the cost. Besides, despite being the world’s highest spender on health, with 40 per cent from the government, US has nearly a third of its people denied access to basic care and a longevity of life among its black populations at about 58! The sharp differences between the US and Canada are largely on account of the values enshrined in their respective constitutions. For the Canadian psyche, it is social solidarity, order, peace and good governance, while for the US it is personal freedom, pursuit of happiness and liberty. And while in both countries provisioning of healthcare services is by private providers, Canada insures all its citizens — rich and poor — inpatient care and physician services, while in the US, public finance is only for specific target groups, namely the poor and the elderly.
- Given the widespread poverty, our intellectual traditions and constitutional pronouncements of equality, it is inexplicable as to why public discourse on health systems has not followed UK or Canada and why we are creating a system resembling the US.
- As in the US, we too do not seem to be troubled by accepting a two-tier system, where the rich can access world class health care as per their ability to pay while the poor must rest content with the public health system. This is worrying, because unlike Singapore, which also has a two tier system with the public hospitals providing the benchmark in quality of care, public health care in India is considered substandard as a result of it being underfunded, understaffed and overstretched.
- Is this gradual veering towards the US model a reflection of our Hinduism which is intensely atomistic and where each lives and suffers in accordance with his own karma?
- Is it really true that concepts of equality and social solidarity are indeed foreign and borrowed and therefore not relevant to India as seems to have been pointed out by the then prime minister to a group of agitated women activists in response to his stand on the famous Shah Bano case?
- Clearly, there is an immense amount of conceptual clutter and lack of direction in our discourse on health. In jumping to ideological positions of public is bad, private is good and governments are bad and markets are good, our intellectuals have trivialised serious debate.
The devastation markets have caused, in terms of human suffering and public spending in the US, have not even been studied. Instead, intellectuals have allowed themselves to fall prey to facile arguments for privatisation such as, for example, that in providing choice of private hospitals, the rich will opt out of the public hospitals providing space for the poor!
- Can we then agree that those who cannot afford healthcare should be denied it and allowed to suffer and die?
- Do we believe that all humans are not equal?
- As all philosophical principles remind us, can there be true happiness and, more importantly, social stability in a society where a large number of its members suffer want and disease?
- Is it then not necessary for turning the debate around and placing the principles of social solidarity and public accountability in health getting precedence over privatisation and a further commercialisation of health?
A national consensus on some of these issues is important for clarity in public policy and for instilling values of compassion and concern in our society at large and among our health professionals in particular. The author is with the Indian Administrative Service. The views expressed here are her own. Read comment[s]
Self-interest is not selfishness
Tuesday, November 22, 2005
Worldliness of texts
The Invention of India
Monday, November 21, 2005
Denial and Demise
The Captive Mind
Lowest tender
Whither European unity?
The Hindu Sunday, Jun 26, 2005
I might sound xenophobic, but I am glad at the recent signs of disintegration of the European Union. I have never been in favour of a strong Europe because that symbolises a new round of neo-colonialism and Eurocentricism; something the colonised world would not like to contend with again, though the imperial agenda of the Empire is implicit in the very processes of globalisation. European well-being does not imply the well-being of minorities and other nations outside it. Suspicion and failure prevail all over Europe owing to a sense of fear at the prospect of a shared future at the enormous cost of sacrificing national sovereignty which will be fully subsumed in a larger vision of a united Europe. National and European bureaucracies continue to behave undemocratically. It is hard to find a medium between common interest and national sovereignty. Europe has to finally go into a protracted spell of introspection.
Re-engaging organised religion
By the very nature of their office, religious leaders are credited with a certain omniscience, and they have the final say on all matters including mundane matters of management in which they are unschooled. Quite apart from the efficiency issue, the system is also open to abuse. In a milieu of rapid expansion, swelling coffers and unbridled authority over men and the riches, asceticism becomes a difficult matter of personal discipline and commitment. With little transparency and accountability within the institutions, there is hardly any external check on normal human failings. When Lord Acton spoke of absolute power corrupting absolutely, he was referring not to political power but to the power of the popes.
- First, it is time to re-examine public and political attitudes towards religious leaders in general and time perhaps that veneration and deification yielded place to a more critical examination. However strong the faith, one cannot take the almost reflexive position that a religious leader can do no wrong and search for other reasons and conspiracies to explain away serious allegations. A religious office has to be clearly separated from the person occupying it, who may be saintly or may be wholly undeserving of respect and trust. And followers of a tradition or members of a sect ought to realise that the defence of the faith calls for defending the doctrine and protecting a religious institution rather than an individual religious leader personally.
- Second, the rules of engagement of religious leaders in the political system need to be understood clearly. The point to be noted here is that religious leaders entering a political debate would be treated with the same attitude of respect or irreverence as the other political players and their followers can hardly expect them to be shown any special deference.
- The third critical issue relates to the structure and regulation of organised religion whose vulnerability to corruption has been recognised in the theology of many faiths.
Crisis of representative democracy
- For one, the practices of civil society organisations promise an exit from centrally controlled, bureaucratic, hierarchical, and oligarchic party structures solely preoccupied with winning the next election.
- Secondly, it is presumed that a multiplicity of agencies in civil society are able to respond immediately to problems and issues that require swift resolution, because they are notably free from rigid and tiresome constraints that characterise older forms of representation.
Whether civil society organisations do not suffer from the same problems that bedevil political parties is however another debate.
Tolerance and growth
Western lifestyles
Our remedies oft in ourselves do lie...
In defence of the speculator
- I just can’t understand why thousands of people, pursuing a full-fledged, legally-sound profession, are being looked at as morally depraved bad-guys.
- Here’s a regular man-next-door, with a family to support, who has chosen to buy and sell stocks for a living.
- He has invested his capital to buy and sell these shares. He has invested his time and mind in studying price movements, maybe even fundamentals of companies.
- He has made efforts to come to grips with the entrails of how trading works. And he’s there to make a profit out of it.
Population policy and health care
- Why does concerns about population growth continue to dominate India's development and health policies?
- How did the idea of relating population growth to poverty come about?
- What has been the nature of debates on population control among Indian intellectuals and international donor agencies?
- Can the agenda of reproductive health fulfil the need for primary health care?
Muslims and the West
Eat the cake and have two too
Left's right
What about our right to dissent? A response from two students of Jawaharlal Nehru University
JOHN THOMAS & NILANJANA SENGUPTA The Indian Express : Saturday, November 19, 2005
The students are half my age and hence need to know that the political ideal they are espousing is primarily because of association, i.e., to please the peers or superiors, and not out of any rational conviction. They are not enough into life for having a balanced view towards money and economy.Dissent need not be a spectacle or mob-anarchic. The democratic freedom we have earned should not be a cover for the Protest industry. Now that we are into the media-era, more sophisticated tools of canvassing should be employed. But for that the dialogue process requires to be transparent and honest, as Habermas would emphasize, and not the irrational zeal of recruiting cadres by hook or by crook. Fraternally, Tusar N. Mohapatra, Posted by: Tusar N. Mohapatra, India, 20-11-2005 at 0243 hours IST