Thursday, April 04, 2024

Delegitimisation of all non-State institutions

 Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra

Anniversary of Sri Aurobindo's arrival in Pondicherry - the significance of 4th April Matrimandir.

The special opening allows the first ray of the rising sun to penetrate directly into the crystal at Matrimandir, an event that happens only once a year in this day. 

#Auroville

https://twitter.com/JayantiRavi/status/1775766211177197775?t=9_grEKDoek1xygOhJGd46w&s=19

"This little door on the eastern side of Matrimandir beholds a sacred memory for all those who love Sri Aurobindo. Only on the 4th of April, every year, this door opens during the sunrise. Every other day of the year, the door remains shut;.."  

#Auroville #SriAurobindo

https://twitter.com/JayantiRavi/status/1775766125265178763?t=l8sBtISQXCdTk8YcPswECw&s=19

If you live in a country and can freely call its government a dictatorship, it is certainly not a dictatorship.

https://twitter.com/MisraNityanand/status/1775101767027745110?t=QzQyjh6vGnwWgixeR6DRiw&s=19

While limited FoE is one feature of dictatorships, the two are not one and the same. 

What defines dictatorship is not the FoE, but the concentration of powers to one autocratic person or group, with weakened institutional constraints to what they can do. Even if they rule by the people’s popular choice.

As I said they are related but not one and the same. 

Totalitarianism and Dictatorship - related but not the same.

https://twitter.com/bhAratenduH/status/1775408081658052700?t=RXa0uyILxdNG9xpTZeRybw&s=19

Indeed, Totalitarianism emerges in an atomised society and acquires the shade of the prevalent political system. The most common form of totalitarianism in effect today is democratic totalitarianism.

Your view goes contrary to every single word I have read on the subject. Either we are talking about different things or you have something new to say on the subject that scholars have missed for a century.

Hannah Arendt, Alexis Tocqueville, J.L. Talmon, Tomislav Sunic to name a few. Diversity is not the symptom of an atomised society. I insist that we are talking about different things.

The totalitarian tendency is agnostic to ethnic composition because the breakdown of communities can and has happened in all kinds of societies.

https://twitter.com/infinitchy/status/1775438824308638113?t=TLeDyZLxaP8S3L8v5RuNwA&s=19

The route to totalitarianism need not necessarily be violent. It can be achieved through peaceful and perfectly legal means. The least talked about deleterious consequence of modern liberal democracy is delegitimisation of all non-State institutions. Democratic exceptionalism abhors any intermediary between the State and citizen. To explain, the State in a modern democratic polity is considered as 'the representative' of all citizens. Implicitly, it is expected that the citizens' primary and predominant loyalty should be to the State alone, making all non-State institutions illegitimate unless expressly sanctioned by the State. That is to say, all institutions exist upon the sufferance of the State. The constitutional and jurisprudential neglect of family which is the fundamental building block of any society is rather deliberate. For, the democratic State perceives family as a barrier in its direct equation with, nay control of citizens. No wonder that across all modern liberal democracies the institution of the family became the first casualty. The atomised and the disintegrating Western societies are living examples of the destruction wrought by the democratic statism. And democratic exceptionalism precedes democratic totalitarianism.

https://twitter.com/MNageswarRaoIPS/status/1775537337553801384?t=NcaXSFWQGyRPryctII2WkQ&s=19

Nice explanation but blaming democracy looks a bit harsh since in spirituality too the family can be a victim. Of course these are theoretical positions for in reality such neat detachment may not be possible. Further spiritual grounding provides multi-layered checks and balances. 

https://twitter.com/SavitriEra/status/1775588929292685521?t=cgML-dLtexVnQX-ax7EKmw&s=19

How do autorickshaw drivers (in Kolkata) perceive sexual harassment on public transport? Scroll.in

https://scroll.in/article/1065774/how-do-autorickshaw-drivers-in-kolkata-perceive-sexual-harassment-on-public-transport

[HTML] Society with Indian Characteristics: Caste, Class, and Species in Contemporary Retellings of the Rāmāyaṇa

JP Oliveira - Journal of Dharma Studies, 2024
This paper analyzes the construction of Indian society in retellings of the Rāmāyaṇa published in India between 2010 and 2020. I focus on the concepts of caste, class, and mythological species. Through discourse analysis of a corpus of retellings … 
K Singh
The University Campus, as a space, had always been an epicentre of cultural praxis. The inherent diversity in this space allows for vibrant debates about the processes of cultural production and consumption. What is the kind of theatre practice that forms …

[PDF] Theorising Decolonial Queerness: Connections, Definitions, Articulations

S BAKSHI - Essays on Decoloniality: Volume, 2024
The labour in addressing the meaning of decolonising knowledge calls forth an honest and thorough critical appraisal of the standardised canon of knowledge without eliding critical questions of privilege in terms of race, gender, sexuality, and …

[HTML] Islands and Beaches in Science and Technology Studies

W Anderson - Science, Technology, & Human Values, 2024
… My pragmatism, or perhaps equivocation, would prove controversial, especially among South Asian scholars understandably sensitive to fascist assertions of Hindutva. Some of them took me to task for mentioning alternative modernities (Abraham …

[HTML] India's Civilizational Imagination of Southeast Asia

U Das
… For instance, the state in India has so far oscillated between a Nehruvian and a Hindutva understanding of the Indian civilization (Chatterjee & Das, 2023). While both these imaginations agree on India’s civilizational greatness reserving a rightful …

Clip the blue bird: Discursive strategies of Hindutva digital mobilization against Twitter in India

KV Bhatia, P Arora - The Information Society, 2024
… 9) argument that online followers and supporters of the Hindutva ideology are diverse and “range from … Hindutva ideology will help unpack how they generate more participation, create diverse networks of followers, appeal to different …

INDIAN PANDEMIC ENTERTAINMENT AESTHETICS AND INFRASTRUCTURE

DS Mini - Media Industries in Crisis: What COVID Unmasked, 2024
The pandemic and quarantine restrictions following the COVID lockdown in India gave way to uncertainty, but also innovative media productions that mark the moment. Short films, diaristic accounts, public service announcements, and films used mobile …

Killing with Kindness: Can a Plague Cure a Plague?

ML Budde - Put Away Your Sword: Gospel Nonviolence in a Violent …, 2024
The world’s been a mess for so long that it’s understandable if you missed or have forgotten about one atrocity among others. On November 27, a report was made public—it spoke of the near-complete slaughter of a religious minority population yet …

[PDF] An International Peer-Reviewed Open Access Journal

R MISTRY
The present research paper is undertaken to explore the diasporic sensibility in the fictional world of Rohinton Mistry. Consequently, the aim of this research is to probe into his works and discover the contemporary new world that unveiled up for the …

Indian Citizenship Revisited

M Majumdar - Social Change, 2024
… evidence-based arguments presented by the authors in these volumes, that recent changes in citizenship laws need to be understood in the light of their ideological and political embedding within a larger field of power, watered carefully …

Book review: Arkotong Longkumer, The Greater India Experiment: Hindutva and the Northeast

S Misra - 2024
… He identifies the prime cultural sites for Hindutva’s operations: the placing of Northeastern India and its indigenous ‘tribal’ religions within the ‘imaginative geography’ of Akhand Bharat, Hindutva’s interface with Christianity and Rani …

Bodies that Dance: Critical Frames of Reference

U Sarkar Munsi - Mapping Critical Dance Studies in India, 2024
Bodies are repositories—whether we like it or not. I, for one Aesthetics , exist in a body that hardly remembers a time when it did not carry any signature dance training. I am told I expressed the desire to enter a dance school when I was three years old …

The Modern and the Contemporary in the Context of Dance in India

U Sarkar Munsi - Mapping Critical Dance Studies in India, 2024
This chapter of the book wants to make identifiable the forms that exist and share the contemporary times, together with reference to the same geography—either in-situ or from some distant locations. Without aspiring to describe all forms that identified …

[PDF] Inter-faith Rituals: Rebuilding the Secular Nation state from the Margins

ナタラジャンマヒマ - 創価大学大学院紀要= The bulletin of the Graduate …, 2024
Is it possible to sustain secular character of a secular nation-state when the union government consciously weaponizes religion for its majoritarian and electoral politics? The present study explores how people positioned at the margins of a nation-state …

The Ups and Downs of Competing Power Rituals

UWE SKODA
With reference to Dasarā rituals in Nepal, Joanna Pfaff-Czarnecka (1998, 577) proposes that “power rituals” in complex sociopolitical orders “express and dramatize social realities, but also... organize social groups by relating them with …

[PDF] The Indian Administration

BR Chinnala - Economic & Political Weekly, 2024
… These developments include (i) the Mandal assertion—a demand of reservations for the socially and economically backward communities in public institutions/ resources; (ii) the Mandir assertion— the Ram Rath Yatra led by powerful Hindutva …

[PDF] Rise of Hindu Nationalism Amongst Some Educated Middle Class Hindu Indians

メーラトュリカ - 創価大学大学院紀要= The bulletin of the Graduate …, 2024
This research discusses the history, and evolution of Hindu nationalism in India, while attempting to understand the different factors and processes leading to its rise. Using the process of Othering as its theoretical framework, this study explores how …

[HTML] Religion, Ecology and Hindu Nationalism in India

E Tomalin - Religion and Development, 2024
In this paper I examine the construction of Hinduism as inherently “environmentally friendly” within religions and ecology discourses and how this construction has been appropriated by the Hindu nationalist movement in India to serve ends that are at …

No comments:

Post a Comment