Sunday, November 20, 2005
Cause and caution
K Natwar Singh
The Hindustan Times: Sunday, November 20, 2005
- Politics need not knowingly slip into the slime and squalor of an endless debasing debate and deliberation.
- Our political and other institutions are under siege by round-the-clock cable TV onslaught in the name of transparency.
- Free speech does not mean freedom to abuse and misinform.
- Subtlety of style and form is now almost extinct as far as the national political dialogue is concerned.
- The establishment of truth should be our primary duty. Not the display of the nastiest emotions — envy, vanity, greed and jealousy.
- Why such ferocious obsession with politics. How about courage, nobility of heart and mind.
- What about using leisure to enjoy life and not aim at squalid intrigue and loathsome verbal over-kill.
- Why this penchant for building edifices of lies.
Some Animals are More Equal than Others
George Orwell's classic, Animal Farm has gone down in popular imagination as the anti-Communist novel of all times. But, looking back on it more than 60 years on, this 90-page satire on dictatorships is much more than an anti-socialist diatribe. Of course it is a political novel, but Orwell's politics embraced a number of issues: the essential nature of all dictatorships, both of the Left and the Right, politics and the corruption of language, the ephemeral nature of human relationships or the only form of real angst, the menace of bureaucracies, but, above all, the commitment of language as the partner of truth. Prima facie, Animal Farm is a short satire on dictatorships. The animals on the farm revolt against their master, Jones. They are successful in getting rid of the tyrant and in managing the practical work of the farm; but they are disastrously unsuccessful over some things they had never regarded as a problem, their dealings with each other. The Revolution is hardly complete before differences appear. The pigs do not actually work, but direct and supervise others. With their superior knowledge, it was natural they should assume the leadership. With the leadership, they also assume the buckets of milk yielded by the cows, and the apples from the orchard. Once there was no longer any danger of Jones's return, a new threat must be found to keep the other animals working their hardest, contented in submission to the pigs. The new threat is himself a pig, Snowball. Long after Snowball has been driven into exile, his name serves as a slogan of hatred: his machinations are held responsible for every failure on the farm, and every animal suspected of disaffection is denounced as an emissary of Snowball. Meantime, the basic principle of the Revolution, " All Animals are Equal", inscribed on the barn wall after the expulsion of Jones, has a qualifying clause — "But Some Animals are More Equal than Others".Animal Farm works as an allegory because the story is coherent on a number of levels. Since it is conceived and written in the classic tradition of satire — the tradition of going back and forth in time or what academics describe as the tradition of "receding planes" — it contains something for every reader. Like Gulliver's Travels or Aesop's Fables, it makes a delightful children's story. It can also be read as a lament for the fate of revolutions. When all is said and done, it was the language of politics that was responsible for the dénouement: "Political language is designed to make lies sound truthful and murder respectable, and to give an appearance of solidarity to pure wind." The Hindu Literary Review Sunday, Aug 07, 2005
The End of Poverty
The charkha spun cobwebs
Thorstein Veblen and Dr. M.N. Srinivas
Wrong shade of red
The Hindustan Times: November 19, 2005Often described as Left extremism, there is a concerted attempt to denounce communism as fostering a ‘cult of violence’ and equating anarchism with revolutionary activities. It needs to be underlined that anarchism is the very antithesis of Marxism and mindless militancy negates — and often regresses — the fundamental tenets of revolutionary activity.The CPI(M) was formed in 1964. Certain sections went on to form the CPI(M-L) in May 1969, based on an erroneous understanding that the Indian ruling classes were a ‘comprador bourgeoisie’, i.e. they were merely agents of imperialism and, hence, did not possess a social force or a mass following domestically, it was, therefore, only a matter of time when they would be overthrown. Thus, there was no necessity to mobilise the people and organise a mass revolutionary party. The people, it is presumed, are ready for a revolution by overthrowing the ruling classes. All that was needed was to arm the people and, hence, emerged the slogan ‘People’s War’. This slogan was accompanied by its twin of ‘annihilation’ of class enemies. The following years saw widespread violence and anarchy. The CPI(M) was the main target as it was seen as ‘obstructing’ this process.Apart from such reprehensible violent activity, there is a serious ideological problem as well. While expressly appropriating ‘Maoism’, they seek to replicate the pre-revolutionary Chinese experience in modern India. By doing so, they negate Mao himself who once said a party which was not able to analyse the situation evolving in its own country and would rather emulate experiences of another country without analysis was a “hotchpotch”. It is a serious ideological flaw to universalise this experience and to seek to impose it under modern Indian conditions.The CPI(M), while rejecting both the ideological positions and the practice of the various Naxalite groups, stated in its programme: “The struggle to realise the aims of the people’s democratic revolution through the revolutionary unity of all patriotic and democratic forces with the workers-peasants alliance at its core, is a complicated and a protracted one. It is to be waged in varying conditions in varying phases. Different classes, different strata within the same class, are bound to take different positions in these distinct phases of the development of the revolutionary movement. Only a strong Communist Party, which develops the mass movements and utilises appropriate united front tactics to achieve the strategic objective, can make use of these shifts and draw into its ranks these sections. Only such a party bringing within its fold the most sincere and sacrificing revolutionaries would be able to lead the mass of the people through the various twists and turns that are bound to take place in the course of the revolutionary movement.” (Article 7.16)“The CPI(M) strives to achieve the establishment of people’s democracy and socialist transformation through peaceful means. By developing a powerful mass revolutionary movement, by combining parliamentary and extra-parliamentary struggle, the working class and its allies will try their utmost to overcome the resistance of the forces of reaction and to bring about these transformations through peaceful means. However, it needs always to be borne in mind that the ruling classes never relinquish their power voluntarily. They seek to defy the will of the people and seek to reverse it by lawlessness and violence. It is, therefore, necessary for the revolutionary forces to be vigilant and so orient their work that they can face up to all contingencies, to any twist and turn in the political life of the country.” (Article 7.18)Social transformation in India, thus, can only be on the basis of the concrete analysis of the concrete conditions that exist in India. It can neither replicate the Russian or the Chinese or for that matter any other experience in the world. The writer is Rajya Sabha MP and Member, CPI(M) Politburo
Charkha stood for self-help
Saturday, November 19, 2005
Spirituality and Sustainability
Happiness doesn’t equal a Mercedes Benz
The Indian Express Sunday, July 28, 2002The United Nations Development Programme’s (UNDP) Human Resource Development indices have been designed on the basis of suggestions and modules provided by the international financial institutions. These mostly relate to and reflect the material development of a society. My basic point is that development of the human personality does not entirely depend on material values. Going by any definition, there are four components in a human personality—body, mind, intellect and soul. Any development parameter should reflect the influences of all these four parameters. For instance, if a society is affluent but fails to impart human values to its individual, then its development indices should not be counted as high. In an affluent society, the crime graph could very high, whereas in a less materially endowed society the same incidents of crime could be low. Which then is the developed or the under-developed society? Similarly, a social set up may have a well evolved aesthetic-cultural value system in place, but can be less affluent with less economic mobility. It is time that we look at the world through a different looking glass—new parameters—in order to understand how peace, democracy and development is inter-connected and inter-dependent. How by encouraging and sustaining the human values of even an under-developed society, the conditions of strife can be reduced. On the question of human value, the conditions that need to be looked into are compassion, the instinct to share with others, tolerance, respect for diversity. A society should also be judged against these inherent human, civilisational values. All these aspects needs to be factored in the indices along with the educational attainment, life expectancy and income levels. There should a redefining of the parameters. Only then can the human development index reflect the true ground reality. There is a need to re-evaluate and re-define what is ‘a developed society’ and what is an ‘under-developed society’. In fact, the UNDP agreed that there is substance in the view that I am taking on the developing of new parameters to evaluate human development index. They agreed that factors like the human values, happiness index of a society, spiritual level of a society should find a place in the parameters.Individuals of a society can attain fulfillment, happiness and sense of achievement without owning a Mercedes car. Whereas, an upwardly mobile society which enables it individuals to achieve a high level of material comfort may not provide mental and spiritual succour.
Friday, November 18, 2005
Robert B. Reich: The liberal ideal
- First, the separation of church and state. We do not want to live in a theocracy. We should maintain that barrier and government has no business telling someone what they ought to believe or how they should conduct their private lives.
- Secondly, liberals are concerned about the concentration of wealth because it almost inevitably leads to a concentration of power that undermines democracy.
The current degree of concentrated wealth in America is a direct threat to our well-functioning democracy. We can see it in the symptoms every day, in terms of campaign financial contributions streaming in to mostly the Bush campaign from corporations. We also see the enormous effect that large corporations have, and the enormous power they wield in Washington simply by virtue of their size and economic power.
- Liberals, thirdly, have always represented opportunity and equality of opportunity, whether it be access to affordable health care, or good education, or a fair chance to get a good job.
The liberal ideal is that everyone should have fair access and fair opportunity. This is not equality of result. It’s equality of opportunity. There’s a fundamental difference. So condemning the working class and the poor to lousy schools and to a health care system that is increasingly skewed toward the privileged violates these basic tenets of liberalism, as does a tax break that is overwhelmingly benefiting those who are already very rich at a time in our nation’s history when the gap between the rich and everyone else is wider than it’s been in over a hundred years.
- And finally, liberals believe in a foreign policy that is multi-national and collaborative, working through the United Nations, NATO and our major allies, seeking to prevent violence and war through spreading middle-class prosperity rather than through the simple assertion of our military might. Our moral authority is as important, if not more important, than our troop strength or our high-tech weapons. We are rapidly losing that moral authority, not only in the Arab world but all over the world.
The silent majority really is a liberal majority, even though the word liberal has taken a real beating over the last 20 years by radical conservatives. The fact is that most Americans support these basic values. They represent mainstream America. The problem is that the radical conservatives are better organized, have more money, and have monopolized more of the airwaves and broadcast media than liberals. Also, the Democrats have been so weak-kneed and have lacked the courage of their convictions.
I’ve spent half of my adult life in public office. I have run for elective office. I’ve spent the other half of my adult life as a student and scholar of the American political and economic system. So I don’t use those words carelessly. I use that example to illustrate the difference between public and private morality. Radical conservatives want to police bedrooms. It’s not government’s business what people do in their private bedrooms. But public morality is quite distinct. And liberals ought to be sounding the alarm about a breakdown of public morality at the highest reaches of corporate America in terms of the looting of corporations, executive salaries that are preposterously out of proportion to what they ought to be, and also corporate contributions and lobbying, and pollution of American politics. These are the real moral failings today, and they need to be understood as such. There is a crisis of public morality. Instead of policing bedrooms, we ought to be doing a better job policing boardrooms.
This is a time when progressives, liberals, people who share these values, need to become more involved than they have at any time since the Vietnam War. The populism that Republicans use is an artificial, superficial populism. It’s a populism that doesn’t really respond to the deep needs of working Americans. In fact, the median wage for workers without college degrees continues to drop, adjusted for inflation, particularly when you consider the erosion -- the steady erosion -- of health benefits. Republicans want to blame affirmative action. They want to blame women and feminists. They blame immigrants, just like they want to blame the French and Germans and anyone else who was not with us in our war in Iraq.
The blame game is a cheap and dangerous form of populism. It doesn’t respond to the underlying issues, the underlying problems. It simply channels people’s anger toward others. It’s divisive. It separates Americans from one another and it separates us from the rest of the world. The kind of populism that Democrats used to espouse was a populism that focused on the genuine needs of working people for better jobs, for health care, for better education, for better opportunities, and the needs of people around the world for expanded opportunities as well. And that’s the kind of populism we need. A BUZZFLASH INTERVIEW: June 14, 2004
Veblen vs. Marx
Marshall McLuhan, Peter Drucker, Alvin Tofler and Robert Reich
Gandhi's India
- non-violence; dialogue; consensus-building;
- love and understanding of the opponent;
- religious tolerance;
- massive employment schemes to give productive employment for India's millions, especially its youth;
- rebuilding India's villages and creating ecumenical communities of care and concern;
- promotion of local handicrafts and skills;
- self-reliance in agriculture and industry;
- production of need-based basic goods and services;
- empowering communities to participate and create their own political structures from bottom-up;
- encouraging self-help projects for human development of all so that swaraj would not result in dependency;
- making basic education a priority;
- ensuring that all Indians irrespective of their religion, caste, class, colour, or education were equal and had equality of opportunity in every sphere of life;
- and that one's moral values would underpin every activity.
The relevance of Hind Swaraj
Drucker can’t die
The one hallmark of the man has been his being way ahead in observing, capturing, analysing new trends and fresh ideas and translating them into insights that are digestible, touchable by the rest of us. I feel a dull aching in my heart, an uneasy vacuum when I realise that this consultant’s consultant, this guru’s guru, this man who has directly influenced the likes of Churchill and Welch, the 20th century’s most influential philosopher has gone without leaving an intellectual heir. He will rest in peace, but his ideas will continue to drive the rest of us. The Indian Express Monday, November 14, 2005
Politics is a drag on Progress
To dispel the confusion over reforms, we need to recognise the failure of the socialist model. A socialist society aims to create an environment in which everyone has equal rights and opportu-nities, the underprivileged are helped and protected to a better life, economic activities are tampered with to meet the needs of the nation and abusive, selfish interests are subjugated. A goal and a society we should all aspire for. But is it possible to achieve this utopian society? If we carry this thought further, we must believe that desire for individual reward for individual effort is anti-social. Practically, however, it is only a minute percentage of people who are able to rise above their personal interest and needs.
We must have under government control items of strategic importance to the country. With this framework in mind, let us examine some of the government's key objectives and the opposition to them: GDP growth rate to be increased from 6 to 8 per cent, which will shorten the time in which the major portion of the population can live decently; and increased outlay on education, health and infrastructure. If these objectives are fine, then the means of achieving them must be acceptable. The main problem in achieving the 8 per cent GDP growth is the gap between what we save as a nation and the investment required to achieve a 8 per cent growth rate. There are two ways to bridge this gap: Foreign direct investment and reduction of dissavings and fiscal deficit. FDI will seek appropriate return, and therefore has to be in the mutual interest of the investor and the country. We must bury the bogey of foreigners controlling our economy.
Can a commercial organisation function outside the laws of the country? The issue of foreign exchange drain can be offset by gains in terms of employment, technology and reciprocity. It is a huge mistake to link employment or job security with getting companies to be efficient and promoting competition. Organised labour accounts for just 10 per cent of the labour force. We cannot hold the country's millions hostage to protecting non-productive employment of organised labour. Labour has and must have rights, but they also have duties. A honest day's work for a day's pay.
Labour laws fair to all is a prerequisite to creating investment and employment. Parts of the public sector are a negative contributor to our savings. Somebody pays for losses of public sector enterprises. It is imperative that these be turned around (if possible), sold or closed down. If current management cannot do it, we offer it to others: If they see value they will bid, or we close them down and salvage what we can. A reduction in deficit becomes important to make funds available for investment in education, health and infrastructure.
To this end, we need to move from a income-based tax bias to one based on consumption. Most countries have gained by moving to VAT. We also need to dump the bogey of taxing the well-to-do at a high rate, as this only results in evasion and corruption. We can reduce non-productive expenditure of the government, by targeting subsidies directly at the less fortunate. For example, the poor do not use LPG; cheap electricity subsidises the rich, who are heavy users of electricity; and the marginal farmer hardly uses fertiliser. Food procurement and distribution is a wasteful mess.
Gandhian economics is relevant
- First, Gandhi advocated the precept of limitation of wants to take care of one's need and not greed. This is a counterpoise to the entire edifice of mainstream economic thinking which is based on the notion of a continuous expansion of the goods space to satisfy unlimited wants. It is conceivable that this may yet turn out to be the single major Gandhian insight that could dictate the agenda of the long-term sustainability of the ecosystem.
- The second has to do with the idea of focusing on the well-being of the poorest and weakest member of society that is contained in Gandhi's talisman. This was one of the last notes that Gandhi left behind in 1948. This was an intrinsic part of Gandhi's moral view of the world. It was articulated at least a decade before John Rawls's early writings. Gandhi's idea, later developed in Rawls's A Theory of Justice published in 1971, was to profoundly alter the course of theoretical welfare economics.
The writer is Director, Delhi School of Economics . THE TIMES OF INDIA : October 3, 2005
Bhutan: Gross National Happiness
Wednesday, November 16, 2005
SAMPADA initiative
Thursday, November 10, 2005
Conversations With Indian Economists
Friday, November 04, 2005
The forgotten Swami Dayanand
A pity that his agenda of social liberation doesn’t interest his followers
VALSON THAMPU
Indian Express, Monday, November 15, 2004
Thursday, November 03, 2005
Multilateral thinking
Vinay Kamat
STOI- 22.2.04
Rule of law
§ ‘we are in bondage to the law so that we might be free’
and that
§ ‘howsoever high you may be, the law is above you.’
We ignore Montesquieu who saw
§ ‘liberty as the right to do as the law permits’
and we violate William Penn’s apt words,
§ ‘Law is the insurance we have on our lives and property. Obedience is the premium we pay for it.’
Abhishek Singvi
HT- 21.4.04