The shift of "rent-seeking" and "entitlement" from neutral terms into heavily pejorative terms happened through two entirely different paths—one born in academic economics and the other in American political and psychological shifts.
Here is how each term became a pejorative:
1. Rent-Seeking: Gordon Tullock and Anne Krueger
In economics, "rent" historically referred simply to income derived from ownership (like land) rather than labor. It wasn't inherently an insult.
- The Concept: Economist Gordon Tullock first outlined the concept in 1967. He argued that when companies spend money to lobby the government for special privileges—like tariffs or monopolies—it wastes society's resources. [1, 2]
- The Pejorative Label: Economist Anne Krueger officially coined and popularized the exact phrase "rent-seeking" in her influential 1974 paper, "The Political Economy of the Rent-Seeking Society". [1, 3]
- Why it is a pejorative: Krueger and Tullock used it to describe a drain on the economy. By definition, rent-seeking is now a negative term used to describe individuals or corporations who manipulate political systems to secure wealth without creating any new value or doing productive work. [4, 5, 6]
2. Entitlement: The Shift from a Legal Right to an Insult
Originally, "entitlement" was a purely neutral legal and political term. In 1945, it was used to describe the G.I. Bill, and in the 1960s, President Lyndon B. Johnson used it proudly to describe Medicare, meaning citizens had a rightful, earned claim to it. [7, 8]
The weaponization of the word happened through two fronts:
| Front | Who Made It Pejorative | How the Meaning Shifted |
|---|---|---|
| Psychology | Robert Coles & Narcissism Researchers (1970s) | Child psychiatrist Robert Coles studied the "children of affluence" and popularized "entitlement" as a psychological flaw—describing wealthy, spoiled children who believed they deserved special treatment without working for it. |
| Politics | Conservative Strategists (Reagan Era / 1980s) | Opponents of the welfare state intentionally dropped the word "earned" from government programs. By calling welfare, Social Security, and food stamps "entitlements," they subtly shifted the definition from a "legal right" to a "demand made by lazy or greedy freeloaders". |
By the 1990s and 2000s, these two streams fused. Today, calling someone "entitled" or labeling a government budget an "entitlement" is almost exclusively used as a disparaging shorthand for unjustified privilege, arrogance, or spoiled behavior. [9, 10]
If you want to dive deeper, would you like to explore how economists measure the financial damage of rent-seeking, or look into other political terms that underwent a similar linguistic shift?
[10] https://www.cjr.org
- GoogleAI
No, "stimulus" is not losing ground to "trigger" globally, but they are undergoing a massive shift in cultural territory. While "stimulus" remains dominant in formal, institutional, and macroeconomic contexts, "trigger" has completely overtaken it in everyday social, psychological, and online speech. [1, 2]
The intersection of these two words comes down to a shift in how we describe cause and effect:
1. The Broadening of "Trigger"
Originally confined to firearms, mechanics, and specific clinical psychology terms (e.g., a "trauma trigger"), "trigger" has undergone massive semantic bleaching. It has evolved into a casual catch-all verb and noun meaning "to cause an immediate reaction" or "an emotional spark". [1, 3, 4]
- In everyday slang: People routinely say "That song triggered a memory" instead of "That song acted as a stimulus for a memory."
- In tech and business: Systems rely on automated triggers (e.g., "an email trigger"), not "stimuli." [1, 5]
2. The Specialization of "Stimulus"
"Stimulus" has not disappeared, but it has retreated into specialized, high-level domains where "trigger" doesn't quite fit:
- Economics: Governments issue economic stimulus packages. Referring to it as a "trigger package" would change the meaning entirely.
- Hard Sciences: In biology, neuroscience, and physiology, organisms still respond to external stimuli. However, even within science, textbooks often note that a stimulus is the agent that triggers a response. [6, 7, 8, 9, 10]
Direct Comparison
| Attribute | Stimulus | Trigger |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Domain | Economics, Biology, Academic Psychology | Everyday Speech, Technology, Pop Psychology |
| Connotation | Nourishing or activating: Implies a spark meant to encourage growth or a mechanical sensory input. | Sudden or disruptive: Implies an immediate, often involuntary or emotional chain reaction. |
| Plural/Verb Usage | Clunky plural (stimuli); rarely used as a natural verb ("to stimulate" has different connotations). | Highly adaptive (trigger, triggers, triggering, triggered). |
Ultimately, "stimulus" is holding its ground in formal writing, but "trigger" has won the battle for modern vernacular because it is highly flexible, functions seamlessly as a verb, and aligns with society's heavy focus on fast-acting, electronic, and emotional cause-and-effect. [1, 2]
Are you analyzing this for a creative writing project, looking at linguistic trends, or drafting a psychology/business text? Let me know, and I can help you choose the best word for your context.
- GoogleAI
Modern psychology and neuroscience largely disagree with Sri Aurobindo’s Integral Yoga on the fundamental source and nature of consciousness. [1]
Nature of Consciousness
- Modern Science: Neuroscience views consciousness as a byproduct or emergent property of physical brain activity and neural networks.
- Sri Aurobindo: Integral Yoga treats consciousness as the fundamental reality of existence—universal and self-luminous—rather than a mere product of matter. [1]
Structure of the Mind and Subconscious
- Modern Science: Western psychology (such as Freudian and Jungian models) maps the mind through surface consciousness, the personal unconscious, and collective archetypes, often blending deeper subtle realms together. [2]
- Sri Aurobindo: Integral Yoga draws a fine-grained map distinguishing the subconscient (the raw storehouse of primitive and repressed reactions) from the subliminal (a vast, luminous inner consciousness behind the surface). It further maps ascending planes above the ordinary mind (Higher Mind, Overmind, Supermind). [2, 3, 4]
Evolutionary Scope
- Modern Science: Evolutionary biology and psychology explain human development through physical adaptation and natural selection.
- Sri Aurobindo: He proposed a spiritual evolution driven by divine "involution," where consciousness progressively manifests from matter to life, mind, and ultimately an inevitable transition to the Supermind. [5]
If you'd like to explore further, let me know if you want to focus on:
- How transpersonal psychology bridges some of these gaps
- Specific therapeutic applications of inner awareness
It is not hard to see ourselves in them — how much of our essential character dwells beneath the surface of the self, how seemingly similar people may differ profoundly in their subterranean essence. It helps to remember that the visible self is fed by an invisible counterpart at least as intricate and extensive; that the two are so tightly stemmed together that we are always interacting with both the visible person and their invisible root system.
Moral emotions are not natural defaults. Love, truth, respect, guilt, compassion and self-restraint are civilizational achievements, developed over centuries through reason, conscience and moral discipline. My latest essay:
[In their higher meanings, love requires concern for the other person’s welfare. Compassion requires recognition of another’s suffering as morally real. Respect requires recognition of dignity. Peace requires inner integration and trust. Truthfulness requires loyalty to reality even when the consequences are painful. None of these higher meanings is instinctive. Left to nature, man is governed by appetite, fear, status, sex, possession, resentment, vanity, and power. Civilization exists precisely to discipline these instincts and transform them into virtues.]
Happy Birthday Modiji, the most vain, narcissistic, megalomanic, paranoid, and absolute reneger and forsworn Prime Minister ever in the history and future of India. I wish you well, but I love my country and countrymen more. So, when you gain insight, please leave.
May Ma Meenakshi Annai and Lord Sundareshwarar whose temple in Madurai is also seeing its Maha Kumbabishekam today shower their blessings on our dear PM @narendramodi ji and his able leadership continue for as long a time as necessary for India. Happy Birthday Modi ji.
What are the odds of the hotel owner talking to me on his breakfast rounds and I tell him how the Aurobindo ashram made me uncomfortable when I last visited and his family turn out to be hardcore ashramites
Most Tamil Brahmins have photos of Aurobondo and "Mother" in their home, in addition to Jiddu Krishnamurti. At least the Hip modern ones. Actual Trads are a microminority. Rural primitivists and literalists rarely survive integration into modernity. Just 2 generations is enough
Interesting, I've never seen Aurobindo or Jiddu among Malayali Brahmins, UC-s or LC-s, except when they're urban and "raita".
The heroic act of extraordinary courage, loyalty and patriotism of Baji Prabho has been immortalised by Sri Aurobindo in his famous poem. I wish that poem is added to high school English language text books in Maharastra. @Dev_Fadnavis motherandsriaurobindo.in/Sri-Aurobindo/…
How can we act without being bound by the fruits of action? Explore the Gita’s profound insights into karma, detachment, self-knowledge and spiritual freedom. Join @PariksithSingh youtu.be/eoVn21bMqSA?si… @MakrandParanspe @AmazingVedas
Why does Krishna tell Arjuna not to grieve? Explore Gita 2.11 with Sri Aurobindo: wisdom begins when we see beyond grief, delusion and the transient to the deeper truth of the Self. Join @PariksithSingh youtu.be/u8m4OU8IFAg?si… @MakrandParanspe @AmazingVedas
THE TRANSNATIONALISATION OF STRATEGIC DIGITAL INFORMATION OPERATIONS
I Yilmaz, P Chacko, S de Groot Heupner, A Sreekumar - Authoritarian Actors and …, 2025
… Prior to the Indian elections in 2024, the websites or social media handles of
Hindutva hate crime tracker websites like Hindutva Watch as well as India Hate Lab
were blocked. The farmer’s protests in India have also led to the censorship of a …
Hindutva hate crime tracker websites like Hindutva Watch as well as India Hate Lab
were blocked. The farmer’s protests in India have also led to the censorship of a …
FUTURE DIRECTIONS IN STRATEGIC DIGITAL INFORMATION OPERATIONS AND WARFARE
I Yilmaz - Authoritarian Actors and Strategic Digital Information …, 2025
This book has undertaken an extensive exploration of SDIOs, offering a novel
framework to understand and analyze the digital manipulation by state and nonstate
actors. The chapters collectively address the theoretical, methodological, and …
framework to understand and analyze the digital manipulation by state and nonstate
actors. The chapters collectively address the theoretical, methodological, and …
OTT services in India
N Bose - Routledge Handbook of South Asian Cinemas, 2025
… This, I argue, is at the center of the Hindutva discourse when it comes to cinema,
as well as SVOD content, including web series. The … Apart from this, we can
observe some degree of pro-Hindutva content on different platforms. In general, the …
as well as SVOD content, including web series. The … Apart from this, we can
observe some degree of pro-Hindutva content on different platforms. In general, the …
Story, sound, and spectacle signifying everything
A Ram - Routledge Handbook of South Asian Cinemas, 2025
In 2023, the American Girl doll franchise owned by Mattel unveiled its first South
Asian doll-Kavi Sharma. The creative team behind the making of the doll included
multi-generational South Asians as advisors. Kavi is fictionally situated in Metheun …
Asian doll-Kavi Sharma. The creative team behind the making of the doll included
multi-generational South Asians as advisors. Kavi is fictionally situated in Metheun …
The Names We Carry With Us
SV KRISHNAMURTI - South Asian Feminisms in Diaspora: Critical …, 2025
… I am in a group supporting Dalit scholars who are being harassed by Hindutva
groups. The strategy, as requested by the Dalit scholars themselves, is to specifically
approach those whose names are identifiably Hindu to sign a letter from “concerned …
groups. The strategy, as requested by the Dalit scholars themselves, is to specifically
approach those whose names are identifiably Hindu to sign a letter from “concerned …
The Dialogic of Praxis
D CHEW - South Asian Feminisms in Diaspora: Critical …, 2025
THIS CHAPTER EVOLVED from the keynote I gave at the Critical South Asian
Feminisms symposium, in July 2021, in what is now called Canada, northern Turtle
Island. 1 I am grateful and honoured to have been part of this rich and exciting …
Feminisms symposium, in July 2021, in what is now called Canada, northern Turtle
Island. 1 I am grateful and honoured to have been part of this rich and exciting …
[PDF] Cultural heritage a way to the past: exploring the cultural heritage in Anita Nair's novel The Better Man
J VG, JCR Gill - Cogent Arts & Humanities, 2025
Heritage, traditional values, and related cultural practices – tools to assess ancestral
lifestyles- are quintessential touchstones for human well-being. Heritage might be in
the form of cultural symbols such as buildings, monuments, artifacts, language, and …
lifestyles- are quintessential touchstones for human well-being. Heritage might be in
the form of cultural symbols such as buildings, monuments, artifacts, language, and …
[PDF] Artmaking As Intervention in Oral History Methodology: Painting Portraits of Queer/Trans South Asian Chosen Family
A Garg - 2025
… There is political significance here, “In this moment that we're seeing [the] rise of
like Hindutva, or Hindu fascism, I think there's something really beautiful in this
tradition that feels important to learn from, to highlight to people who, love this music …
like Hindutva, or Hindu fascism, I think there's something really beautiful in this
tradition that feels important to learn from, to highlight to people who, love this music …
[HTML] Inflammatory Propaganda and the Shadows of Partition: The Role of RSS's Organiser and HMS's Hindu Rashtra in 1947 Communal Violence
SSEO Tools
… The RSS and HMS, though ideologically aligned in Hindutva, diverged in
approach. RSS focused on grassroots mobilization, viewing media as a tool for
ideological indoctrination. Organiser—its first formal organ—blended editorials with …
approach. RSS focused on grassroots mobilization, viewing media as a tool for
ideological indoctrination. Organiser—its first formal organ—blended editorials with …
Right-wing populists and noisy politics for big business
A Avigur-Eshel - Contemporary Politics, 2025
Right-wing populists harbour suspicion toward big business, so the literature finds.
Despite their general sympathy for private capital, they have been found to manifest
outright hostility toward big business or construct uneasy cooperation with it. Hostility …
Despite their general sympathy for private capital, they have been found to manifest
outright hostility toward big business or construct uneasy cooperation with it. Hostility …
Language Proficiency and Linguistic Citizenship: Rethinking Multilingual TESOL Through an Emotional Geography of Languages
A Ahmed - Multilingual TESOL: De-constructing and Re …, 2025
This chapter focuses on how a multilingual approach to TESOL has the potential to
rethink students’ language proficiency and linguistic citizenship. Through this
discussion, I show why developing students’ language proficiency alone—and …
rethink students’ language proficiency and linguistic citizenship. Through this
discussion, I show why developing students’ language proficiency alone—and …
Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra
No comments:
Post a Comment